Defaults are the worked example below, so the first numbers you see are already checked.
Offer A
Offer B
The verdict
—
| Offer A | Offer B | Difference (B − A) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year-1 total (incl. signing bonus) | — | — | — |
| Ongoing annual total (excl. signing bonus — the number that repeats) | — | — | — |
| Monthly (ongoing) | — | — | — |
| Effective hourly rate (ongoing ÷ hours actually worked) | — | — | — |
| Retirement match | — | — | — |
| Health + commute cost (annual) | — | — | — |
| Paid days off | — | — | — |
| Commute time (hours/year) | — | — | — |
| Hours worked (per year) | — | — | — |
—
The fit score — what money can't price
Score each offer 1–5 on the five things that decide whether you will still like the job in a year. The weights are set before you score — growth 25, manager & team 20, flexibility 20, stability 15, the work itself 20 — so you can't quietly move the goalposts toward the offer you already want. Score honestly: the interview process is the best preview you will get of the people.
Offer A
Fit score: — / 100
Offer B
Fit score: — / 100
—
Before you sign — ask these in writing
- Is the bonus guaranteed or discretionary? Get the target, the payout history and the conditions in the offer letter — a bonus you have never seen paid is worth $0 in this calculator.
- When does the retirement match vest, and when do health benefits start? A 3-year vesting cliff or a 90-day benefits wait can be worth thousands in year 1.
- What is the equity vesting schedule? Four years with a one-year cliff is standard; ask for the strike price, the current valuation and what happens to unvested equity if you leave.
- When is the first pay review, and what decides it? A $5,000 gap closes fast if one offer reviews in 6 months and the other in 18.
- Confirm the working pattern in writing. Days in office, on-call expectations, overtime norms — the verbal promise and the contract are not always the same document.
Worked example 1 (the defaults): Offer A — $90,000 base, 4% match ($3,600), health $150/mo ($1,800/yr), commute $100/mo ($1,200/yr), 20 days off, 40 hrs/week. Year-1 total = $90,000 + $3,600 − $1,800 − $1,200 = $90,600; ongoing the same (no signing bonus); 1,920 hours worked a year, so the effective hourly rate is $47.19. Offer B — $105,000 base, $5,000 signing, $5,000 bonus, 3% match ($3,150), health $200/mo ($2,400/yr), commute $300/mo ($3,600/yr), 10 days off. Year-1 total = $105,000 + $5,000 + $5,000 + $3,150 − $2,400 − $3,600 = $112,150; ongoing $107,150; 2,000 hours worked, hourly $53.58. Offer B is ahead by $16,550 a year ongoing ($1,379.17 a month) — but it costs 130 more commute hours a year and 10 fewer days off. If the fit score says A, the question is whether A's fit is worth $16,550 a year to you.
Worked example 2 — the flip: Offer A $72,000 base with a 5% match ($3,600), health $100/mo, commute $50/mo → ongoing $73,800. Offer B $78,000 base, no match, health $150/mo, commute $250/mo → ongoing $73,200. The offer with $6,000 less salary is worth $600 a year more — the match and the commute erased the whole gap. This is why the headline number is the worst way to compare.
Worked example 3 — the fit score: Offer A rated 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 across growth, manager, flexibility, stability and work → 25×4 + 20×4 + 20×5 + 15×4 + 20×4 = 420 ÷ 5 = 84 / 100. Offer B rated 3, 3, 2, 3, 3 → 280 ÷ 5 = 56 / 100. Money says B, fit says A — a split verdict, and the $16,550 gap is the price of choosing fit.
Why this page exists: benefits are roughly a third of what you are actually paid. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026) puts benefits at 31.6% of total compensation for civilian workers — $15.61 of every $49.46 an hour — and 30.0% for private-industry workers. Comparing two offers by base salary alone ignores nearly a third of the package. As a rule of thumb, a gap under about 3–5% between the two ongoing totals is noise — let the fit score decide it.